Topic: Going to Buy a Roll Cage Tubing Bender

I'm in the process of building a new racing headquarters for the Tunachuckers and while I have most of the tools and equipment I _think_ I'll need, the one thing I really, really want to be truly dangerous is a roll cage tubing bender.  After some research, budget looking-at, and 8 ball consulting, I'm pretty sure I'm going to go with a JD Squared Model 32.  I'm planning on going manual first, and upgrading to hydraulic if it gets serious. 

Question for the peanut gallery: The die combinations are various and sundry:

https://www.jd2.com/p-50-m32-round-die-sets.aspx

I'm considering buying a 1.75 die set; for Lemons duty that will cover any cage I could want to build for any car.  But, what I really need to know is, what radius curve is good for roll cages?  I'd like to buy one die (at least at first, I'm sure there will be more later) that does most of what I need to do.  Tighter radius (5.5")?  Wider radius (6.5" or 7.5")?  Do I really need the 180 degree bend capability (I don't think I do- seems like all the bends in roll cages are <90 degrees)?  Am I completely batshit insane to even be considering this?

Also: what do the experienced folks thing about tubing notchers?  Recommendations?  I've used my drill press to do some notching, are the purpose-built notchers worth the cost?  How fancy does it have to be to be worth it?

Tunachuckers: 15 Years of Effluency
'08 - '10: 1966 Volvo 122, "Charlie"
'10 - '18: 1975 Ford LTD Landau --> 2018 - current: Converted into 1950 "Plymford"
'22 - current: 1967 Volvo 122, "Charlie ]["

Re: Going to Buy a Roll Cage Tubing Bender

Minimum tube bends need to be 3x the tubing diameter.  If you are only getting one set of dies, you are going to want the tightest bends possible to be able to fit the cage as close to the chassis as possible.  I've never had to make a >90* single bend but I have made bends close to each other that have totaled around 135*.

I bought a cheap notcher from HF (2 now actually).  I'm not estatic about it, but it does it's job and I can't imagine doing a cage without it.  Get good bi-metal bits and keep the cutting area lubed.

--Rob Leone Schumacher Taxi Service
We won the IOE at Southern Discomfort.
We got screwed at The Real Hoopties of New Jersey  and we took cars down with us.
We got the curse at Capitol Offense but they wouldn't let us destroy the car.

3 (edited by rodknox2 2011-07-14 08:32 AM)

Re: Going to Buy a Roll Cage Tubing Bender

NASA's CCR states: "The center radius of the bends may not be less than three (3) times the outside diameter of the roll cage tubing."

I think this is a good starting point.

As for benders,  we use a ProTools one shot air over hydraulic hb302. http://www.pro-tools.com

We use the Lowbuck notcher, http://www.lowbucktools.com.  They say it can fish mouth in 6 seconds...don't believe them...it takes me at least 30 seconds.  It isn't cheap, but it will last a life time...we've been using ours for 20 years.

Re: Going to Buy a Roll Cage Tubing Bender

When I went to my Uncle's shop, he had a notcher that would just take a bite out of the tubing in about 1/2 second.  I'd imagine it was quite pricey, though.

Silent But Deadly Racing-  Ricky Bobby's Laughing Clown Malt Liquor Thunderbird , Datsun 510, 87 Mustang (The Race Team Formerly Known as Prince), 72 Pinto Squire waggy, Parnelli Jones 67 Galaxie, Turbo Coupe Surf wagon.(The Surfin Bird), Squatting Dogs In Tracksuits,  Space Pants!  Roy Fuckin Kent and The tribute to a tribute to a tribute THUNDERBIRD/ SUNDAHBADOH!

5 (edited by mechimike 2011-07-14 08:52 AM)

Re: Going to Buy a Roll Cage Tubing Bender

So, if using 1.75" OD tubing, the radius must be no less than 1.75*3 or 5.25" or greater.  It looks like the smallest radius they sell is a 5.5" for that tube diameter, so that should be fine.  Wider radius would potentially be stronger, but harder to fit into the chassis.  Trade Off.

Anyone have experience with the lowbuck hydraulic bender?  I was vacillating between that one and the JD Squared, but have not read anything about the Williams (LB) model.

Tunachuckers: 15 Years of Effluency
'08 - '10: 1966 Volvo 122, "Charlie"
'10 - '18: 1975 Ford LTD Landau --> 2018 - current: Converted into 1950 "Plymford"
'22 - current: 1967 Volvo 122, "Charlie ]["

Re: Going to Buy a Roll Cage Tubing Bender

We have three dies 1 3/4 1 5/8 1 1/2  It's nice having your own bender and welder.  It makes all the cars potential Lemons when you don't have to factor in the extra 2K to add a cage.

This space for rent.

Re: Going to Buy a Roll Cage Tubing Bender

NSF wrote:

We have three dies 1 3/4 1 5/8 1 1/2  It's nice having your own bender and welder.  It makes all the cars potential Lemons when you don't have to factor in the extra 2K to add a cage.

That's the scary bit...I've got at least 2 more potential Lemons cars (The Corvair and an unnamed *secret* car) sitting at home.

Depending how well my first cage turns out, how much I like doing it, etc, I may offer my services to others, too.

Tunachuckers: 15 Years of Effluency
'08 - '10: 1966 Volvo 122, "Charlie"
'10 - '18: 1975 Ford LTD Landau --> 2018 - current: Converted into 1950 "Plymford"
'22 - current: 1967 Volvo 122, "Charlie ]["

Re: Going to Buy a Roll Cage Tubing Bender

I have this one http://www.pro-tools.com/200.htm - it rocks.  Especially when you pay some kids to pump it for you or you pick up a Air/Hydraulic Bottle Jack from HF (be very careful doing that as there are fitment issues).

--Rob Leone Schumacher Taxi Service
We won the IOE at Southern Discomfort.
We got screwed at The Real Hoopties of New Jersey  and we took cars down with us.
We got the curse at Capitol Offense but they wouldn't let us destroy the car.

Re: Going to Buy a Roll Cage Tubing Bender

Oh, and being able to do our own cages and knowing that we are going to pass tech brings piece of mind.  Knowing that every bend/weld/plate was done right...

--Rob Leone Schumacher Taxi Service
We won the IOE at Southern Discomfort.
We got screwed at The Real Hoopties of New Jersey  and we took cars down with us.
We got the curse at Capitol Offense but they wouldn't let us destroy the car.

10 (edited by SoFlacrapcan 2011-07-14 02:15 PM)

Re: Going to Buy a Roll Cage Tubing Bender

I just ordered the Pro4 Probender LE yesterday from www.probender.com , I can't wait to get it and see what I can do. Still need to find a source for materials though. I've called multiple local places and they all don't carry any DOM.

For $340 shipped you can buy a bender from www.affordablebender.com . I have seen a cage made with one and it looked great. But I figured I'd spend a little more and get one thats more substantial, and hope to do more then a few cages with.

Re: Going to Buy a Roll Cage Tubing Bender

SoFlacrapcan wrote:

For $340 shipped you can buy a bender from www.affordablebender.com . I have seen a cage made with one and it looked great. But I figured I'd spend a little more and get one thats more substantial, and hope to do more then a few cages with.

I've heard because the dies in this type of bender are only 90 degrees total that they will only do a 75 degree bend.  I've never used one, anyone with expirence?  The 90 degree dies for other higher end benders are actually 110 degrees, just something to think about when shopping for a bender for roll cages.

If it doesn't have 2 doors, 3 pedals, and 5 lug nuts per wheel - It isn't a real race car

12

Re: Going to Buy a Roll Cage Tubing Bender

JD2 M-3 is the best bang for the buck.

IMHO

This space for rent.

Re: Going to Buy a Roll Cage Tubing Bender

I have a greenleee conduit bender, works fine for Lemons cages. can do 90's and 1 3/4 tubing no problem. Little time consuming. But will get the job done cheap. Got mine on ebay for 230.00 it a stand up model. manual works great.

If its not broke fix it till it is...

Re: Going to Buy a Roll Cage Tubing Bender

Greenlee model 1801 saw one on ebay for 139.00 used. plus shipping. 1801 has the bigger head and say up to 1 1/2 but 1 3/4 will fit..

If its not broke fix it till it is...

Re: Going to Buy a Roll Cage Tubing Bender

04crx wrote:

Greenlee model 1801 saw one on ebay for 139.00 used. plus shipping. 1801 has the bigger head and say up to 1 1/2 but 1 3/4 will fit..

Thats a conduit bender...  not a tubing bender... please don't use it on race car tube.

Gosh, my business card says 'Tech Tyrant'

Re: Going to Buy a Roll Cage Tubing Bender

JD2 makes a great bender but is notorious for very long lead times.  To avoid long waits or to get real world lead times, deal with a good reseller like Van Sant. http://www.vansantent.com/ I bought a Pro Tools 105HD becuase found lots of good feedback on both the tool and the company on various off road forums.

Now that I have used both, I can honestly say that either brand of rotary draw bender will give you high quality bends and repeatable bend performance.

http://www.ducttapemotorsports.com/
http://www.teamdfl.com
"I can see it now, a pile of nickels and all the glory of being a real race car driver."
Prepping the Red wReck for the 24 Hours of Lemons

Re: Going to Buy a Roll Cage Tubing Bender

My team was in the same position as yours a couple months ago, we went the JD2 Model 3 route and couldn't be happier!  Build quality is awesome, works like a charm, and unlike Greenlee "conduit benders" the bends are clean and ripple free.  We went with the 1.5" die x 4.5" bend radius.

At work I've done a bit of notching with drill presses and crappy handhelds setups, not okay for cage building.  I guarantee you'll be doing enough notching to make a quality tool worth the time savings, not to mention the material wasted with bad notches.  We went with the JD2 Notchmaster and a cheap, bi-metal hole saw.  Lots of cutting oil and it works like a dream.  Again, overbuilt but so easy to use!

My dad taught me very young, buy GOOD tools and you won't regret it!  Now every car I look at is a possible Lemons car, being able to BYO cage does that to you...  wink

Lemons noob team shooting for 1st race @ Chicago-Autobahn Oct '11
---< Team Rollin' Dough >---
'88 CRX Pizza Delivery Jitney

Re: Going to Buy a Roll Cage Tubing Bender

I learned a long time and many busted knuckles ago to buy better tools than you think you can afford.  I once saw this sign- it was at a vacuum cleaner repair shop, but it holds true for just about anything in life:

"The bitterness of poor quality lingers long after the sweetness of low price has been forgotten"

Or, in my case, until you hurl that @#$% Pittsburgh brake line bender at the concrete wall after the handle broke and cut your hand.

Tunachuckers: 15 Years of Effluency
'08 - '10: 1966 Volvo 122, "Charlie"
'10 - '18: 1975 Ford LTD Landau --> 2018 - current: Converted into 1950 "Plymford"
'22 - current: 1967 Volvo 122, "Charlie ]["

Re: Going to Buy a Roll Cage Tubing Bender

In my opinion, notchers are unnecessary.  I've done plenty of tube fitment with a plasma cutter and a grinder.  It's confusing at first but you get the hang of it.

I've always found that the real tricky bit is getting the length right on tubes that need to be notched on BOTH ends.  That's to say, it's harder to find the right placement for the notch than it is to get the notch shaped correctly.

But hey, that's just me.

If it ain't broken, fix it 'til it is.

Re: Going to Buy a Roll Cage Tubing Bender

I have both the JD2 bender and notcher.  I love both of them and they have great build quality.  I would love to rig up the JD2 on it's side with a bottle jack like I have seen in a few videos, but it doesn't take THAT much force to merit that doing it the manual way.

Namco Racing #48 Miata

Re: Going to Buy a Roll Cage Tubing Bender

After swinging the 4 foot handle on a couple roll bars, I think Lemony hydraulic conversions are fantastic.  I used an 8 ton jack from the local import tool emporium and some steel plate from the scrap bins at a friend's shop to build mine.  The jack has a manual handle and a built in an air over oil pump

http://teamdfl.com/Lemons/bender.jpg

http://www.ducttapemotorsports.com/
http://www.teamdfl.com
"I can see it now, a pile of nickels and all the glory of being a real race car driver."
Prepping the Red wReck for the 24 Hours of Lemons

22 (edited by SoFlacrapcan 2011-07-18 02:45 PM)

Re: Going to Buy a Roll Cage Tubing Bender

Kit to add harbor freight hydraulic ram to bender, resonably cheap. Supposed to work with JD2, Pro Tools, JMR
http://www.swagoffroad.com/Tubing_Bende … Mount.html

Re: Going to Buy a Roll Cage Tubing Bender

I've had a TUBESHARK for 15 years now, great machine and it folds up and stashes in the corner . Great company had a couple things break and they warranties it .

I used my buddies JD model 4 with him at his shop and would definitely a replacement if something ever happen to TUBESHARK .


Definitely invest in good tubing notcher I had a $50 harbour freight for years then got a Protools notcher is great notcher . It's mounted on a piece of flat steel welded to tubing and then dropped it in a 5 gallon bucket with concrete. All  the shavings Fall in bucket and its portable..

Also get the bend tech pro  software makes bending easier.

Pit Crew Revenge Racing   Rolling chicanelimo,95Lamdspeeder,Gimp Pimp Cadi,300zx Car show kaboom!! 90 Wagovan, mazda v8 Lemons LOGO TATTOO!  Aces 84 Cadi Eldo Briattz I O E WINNER
Class C win with LemonOdy Cannonball Run Whambulance !EX K Captain
Lemons Trophy Truck ShaGuar Baby!

Re: Going to Buy a Roll Cage Tubing Bender

fabtoys wrote:

Also get the bend tech pro  software makes bending easier.

Huh?  Software to bend?  Please elaborate.

Re: Going to Buy a Roll Cage Tubing Bender

http://www.bend-tech.com/

http://www.bend-tech.com/products.htm
EZ handles simple planar bends.  EZ3D can handle out of plane bends.  Pro allows you to design assemblies.  I bought Bend Tech Pro and love it.

http://www.ducttapemotorsports.com/
http://www.teamdfl.com
"I can see it now, a pile of nickels and all the glory of being a real race car driver."
Prepping the Red wReck for the 24 Hours of Lemons