We started running Lemons at MSR Houston in the Fall of 2008.
We run a 1973 240Z that I have upgraded to disc brakes all the way around with 300ZX (Z31) rotors on all 4 corners.
In that race we ran Porterfield R4s in the front with Hawk HP+s in the rear and Valvoline Synpower fluid.
The HP+ did not grip enough to keep an even front rear bias. We did that because we thought the larger rear discs would grip more than the front. We were wrong.
After that race we switched the rear to Porterfield R4-1s. It's a vintage race pad that requires a bit less heat. Our bias was about right at the point.
We ran the car like this through 3 MSR Houston races and 1 New Orleans. The front pads had 4 MSR races on them.
For Eagles Canyon we did a brake job and kept the car the same way it had been. We wore through most of the fresh pads between practice and the 10 hour session on Saturday.
So our first set of front pads lasted 5 races, rears lasted 4 easily. One trip to Eagles Canyon and we had more brake wear in 10 hours than the previous 5 races combined.
We had some mild softening of the pedal so we most have gotten the fluid a bit hot and we warped the rotors.
We raced on 225/40R14 Toyo T1Rs for our initial 6 events.
For our most recent race at MSR Houston, Sept 2010, we put on Raybestos pads and 205/50r15 Dunlops Star Specs with Motul fluid. The car is a bit different but very drivable.
While race pads are more expensive they tend to last longer. So I am sure you get more out of your money in the long run and you're safer.
I have no experience with Carbotech pads.
My only complaint about Porterfield is sometimes things are a bit slow out of the door. Granted they tend to have to make the stuff we order so keep in mind you need to order your stuff with plenty of lead time. That said, I plan to continue to get my brakes through Porterfield.
Put good stuff on your car, the ass your save could be mine.
Troy
#35 LRE
1973 Datsun 240Z