Topic: Is there a rule on bringing a back up car?

Having driven 10 hours to an event only to have the car die at the end of the 1st day. I would like to know if there is a rule about bringing a 2nd car as insurance.

I am building a 2nd car for next year because of the amount of events we would like to run. I feel rather than rush to get a blown engine Etc replaced in a month prior to another race it would be easier to have a 2nd car.  Plus I am  trying to go with the spirit of the event and build a  Retro car and only use the E30 for the big tracks. Or ½ the events.

SO back to the question.  If we brought up a 2nd car and also had it tech-ed  and agree that once the 2nd car went out we would no longer be Officially in the race. ( so no laps counted) .Can we do this??  I am more interested in getting the seat time, being able to drive  VS sitting on the side line for the 2nd day.

Judges?

EuroTrash E30 - Lemons South 08 (cooling probs) 24th /CMP  Spring 09 (fuel tank damage) one day on track 69th /Lemons South 09 (Hit by an Escort) 27th
MSR Tx, 10 2oth, no issues other than rain. /CHump Homestead Miami 10- 2nd place.

Re: Is there a rule on bringing a back up car?

bam2002 wrote:

Having driven 10 hours to an event only to have the car die at the end of the 1st day. I would like to know if there is a rule about bringing a 2nd car as insurance.

I am building a 2nd car for next year because of the amount of events we would like to run. I feel rather than rush to get a blown engine Etc replaced in a month prior to another race it would be easier to have a 2nd car.  Plus I am  trying to go with the spirit of the event and build a  Retro car and only use the E30 for the big tracks. Or ½ the events.

SO back to the question.  If we brought up a 2nd car and also had it tech-ed  and agree that once the 2nd car went out we would no longer be Officially in the race. ( so no laps counted) .Can we do this??  I am more interested in getting the seat time, being able to drive  VS sitting on the side line for the 2nd day.

Judges?

I know what I would say but because this a "flame free zone" I won't say it.

Flaming........Hot!

Team: V-Ram/Altamont Team: Knights of the Round Track/Reno/Buttonwillow/Thunderhill Team: Death Mobile/Sears 2010/Thunderhill/ChumpCar  Spokane/ MSR Houston/Buttonwillow/Sears. MRolla Project /Reno
http://stickfigureracing.blogspot.com/

Re: Is there a rule on bringing a back up car?

I see no reason to flame.  It brings up an interesting point.

IF the car was also teched as a true Lemons contender and IF once you go to the backup car you are out of contention for any awards, what's the harm, right?

The only thing I can think of that would make it undoable is that some teams would treat this as a free pass to drive like total asshats once they get to the backup car.

Re: Is there a rule on bringing a back up car?

I second Blacksheep1 in saying that I don't see what the harm is.  The guy wants insurance against being stuck on the sidelines.  The only thing that I can see that would cause a problem is jealousy.  The "rich" teams would have backup cars, but the "poor" teams would not.  I totally understand trying to guard against being stuck watching instead of driving because our POS racer chucked a rod on saturday morning.

Re: Is there a rule on bringing a back up car?

It's been done a couple of times.  We did it at Stafford this year, another team did it the year before, and a team did it at Nelson.  We brought another Lemons car so we fit right in, but the other team at Nelson brought a spec Miata.  They drove like asshats, caused at least one accident, and Jay ended up taking the keys out of the car - that story is posted around here somewhere.

--Rob Leone Schumacher Taxi Service
We won the IOE at Southern Discomfort.
We got screwed at The Real Hoopties of New Jersey  and we took cars down with us.
We got the curse at Capitol Offense but they wouldn't let us destroy the car.

6 (edited by Bender/StickFigureRacing 2009-12-17 08:20 AM)

Re: Is there a rule on bringing a back up car?

I guess I would have no problem with having a second car if the team was willing to pay the addtional $500.00 per car for the extra insurance. I just don't see it being done in the spirit of Lemons. In my opinion part of these races is dealing with the hardship of keeping your car on the track. Not just replacing it with another one half way through because the first one doesn't work the way you want it to. I.E Heroic Fix Award...

Team: V-Ram/Altamont Team: Knights of the Round Track/Reno/Buttonwillow/Thunderhill Team: Death Mobile/Sears 2010/Thunderhill/ChumpCar  Spokane/ MSR Houston/Buttonwillow/Sears. MRolla Project /Reno
http://stickfigureracing.blogspot.com/

Re: Is there a rule on bringing a back up car?

Yep.  Now that Bender says that, I sort of see that side of it, too.  The nobility of the Lemons is in the struggle.  Maybe the second $500 fee would be enough to make people think twice about whether they were really committed to the back-up car concept.  Of course, I can't imagine the race organizers would really object that strongly to taking a second $500 car fee from the same team, particularly if said car wasn't taking up any additional space on the track. NO spec Miatas though.  That's lame. The second car should have to be a true Le Mon, just like all the other cars.

Re: Is there a rule on bringing a back up car?

If the 2nd car has a good working motor in it, and the motor in your primary car expires - feel free to take the motor OUT of the 2nd car and put it into the first one.  That'll get you back out there.

Just swapping entire cars seems a bit out of line to me.  I'd have you enter two cars, and you can't combine the laps between them.  Hell, if that's the case, I'll enter 3 cars, with 12 drivers - and accumulate one MILLION laps [Dr. Evil grin...] between them all.

We've debating bringing a complete spare motor to stick in - and so far, we haven't.  We only bring component parts (ie. cylinder head, suspension assemblies, gaskets, etc) - and we fix it when it breaks.  We do a lot of prep work prior to the race to give the car the best possible chance of finishing.  Even then, sh*t breaks - it's part of the event.

"Chief Idiot" - Italian Stallions Rotary X1/9
Class Win (Bad) / IOE Win (Guzzi Fiat 600) / We Got Screwed / GRM Most from Least

Re: Is there a rule on bringing a back up car?

Personally, I find the idea of a back up car kind of preposterous. Granted, Lemons isn't really comparable to almost any other racing series on the planet, but having said that, there is no other racing series that allows for a back up chassis to enter the race once the original chassis has started the race. A lot of what makes this race fun and interesting is seeing guys wrenching on their cars for hours on end (and overnight, in many cases) and then getting those cars back on track. I'm all for bringing crappy spare parts for our crappy cars, but am opposed to swapping cars. That gets pretty close to checkbook racing, which is exactly what the Lemons rules are designed to prevent. Cheers.

Pat Mulry, TARP Racing #67

Mandatory disclaimer: all opinions expressed are mine alone & not those of 24HOL, its mgmt, sponsors, etc.

10 (edited by Troy 2009-12-17 08:54 AM)

Re: Is there a rule on bringing a back up car?

I have thought about this for local races.  For events farther away, that's more crap to get to the track and a more crowded paddock.

I have a car up my sleeve that could work but it still needs brakes and tires plus whatever it needs to actually be running..

I thought about it as a back up for our car or for guys who's cars blew up.  If you start loaning it out, that can get real tricky real fast.

I would not want to pay another $500.

Troy

#35 LRE
1973 Datsun 240Z

Re: Is there a rule on bringing a back up car?

Cmice, that's great, assuming someone on your team is 23 years old, full of piss and vinegar, and has the steam to do all that wrenching and then race the next day on no sleep.  But what about a team of older guys who have a few extra pounds, maybe a touch of arthritis, and a turbulent relationship with their torque wrenches.  Should they become instant spectators for the whole weekend just because it would take them 4 days and two emergency room visits to swap out an engine? The suggestion was that once the first car died and recieved it's last rights, the rest of the racing for that team in the replacement car would no longer qualify for lap totals or prizes.  I just don't see the harm in it.  Do you?

Re: Is there a rule on bringing a back up car?

dpvog wrote:

Cmice, that's great, assuming someone on your team is 23 years old, full of piss and vinegar, and has the steam to do all that wrenching and then race the next day on no sleep.  But what about a team of older guys who have a few extra pounds, maybe a touch of arthritis, and a turbulent relationship with their torque wrenches.  Should they become instant spectators for the whole weekend just because it would take them 4 days and two emergency room visits to swap out an engine? The suggestion was that once the first car died and recieved it's last rights, the rest of the racing for that team in the replacement car would no longer qualify for lap totals or prizes.  I just don't see the harm in it.  Do you?

Oh cry me a river!
Our youngest guy is 40 years old and our oldest is 60. You do not want to go with the age thing that will just piss a lot of the older guys like me off. Oops! sorry Flaming again big_smile

Team: V-Ram/Altamont Team: Knights of the Round Track/Reno/Buttonwillow/Thunderhill Team: Death Mobile/Sears 2010/Thunderhill/ChumpCar  Spokane/ MSR Houston/Buttonwillow/Sears. MRolla Project /Reno
http://stickfigureracing.blogspot.com/

Re: Is there a rule on bringing a back up car?

dpvog wrote:

Cmice, that's great, assuming someone on your team is 23 years old, full of piss and vinegar, and has the steam to do all that wrenching and then race the next day on no sleep.  But what about a team of older guys who have a few extra pounds, maybe a touch of arthritis, and a turbulent relationship with their torque wrenches.

Nobody on our team is under 40.  So quit yer bitchin, whippersnapper.  There are plenty of youngsters who'd love to get involved - so sucker them into doing all the dirty work in exchange for beer or strippers or something.  You're old, wise and rich - work it, baby. wink

With the right tools, swapping motors doesn't need to be deadly.  Better yet, get a simple car like a VW bug.  You can drop the motor in that with 4 bolts and a floor jack.

It's a race - there are no guarantees that everybody gets to play/win/lap.  It's up to you, your car, and your team.

"Chief Idiot" - Italian Stallions Rotary X1/9
Class Win (Bad) / IOE Win (Guzzi Fiat 600) / We Got Screwed / GRM Most from Least

Re: Is there a rule on bringing a back up car?

Okay then, Bender, have it your way.  I don't care how many miles you had to walk to school barefoot.  Us spoiled kids today want it easier.  We're bringing our damn ipods, and if we've saved enough money from our paper route to spring for a second $500 car fee just to make sure we're not spending the weekend underneath a car instead of inside it, what do you care?  MOM!?!  Why does Grandpa Bender have to live with us???

Re: Is there a rule on bringing a back up car?

dpvog wrote:

Cmice, that's great, assuming someone on your team is 23 years old, full of piss and vinegar, and has the steam to do all that wrenching and then race the next day on no sleep.  But what about a team of older guys who have a few extra pounds, maybe a touch of arthritis, and a turbulent relationship with their torque wrenches.  Should they become instant spectators for the whole weekend just because it would take them 4 days and two emergency room visits to swap out an engine? The suggestion was that once the first car died and recieved it's last rights, the rest of the racing for that team in the replacement car would no longer qualify for lap totals or prizes.  I just don't see the harm in it.  Do you?

This almost precisely describes our situation at the Houston race in October. And, for that matter, at the Nelson Ledges race. Our youngest guy is 37 and hasn't been anything close to slender in more than 20 years. We had 2 guys wrenching for the better part of 12 hours who saw their 60th birthdays several years ago. We're not exactly whipper snappers, but I guess we are still full of piss and vinegar.

At Houston, we blew up the race motor basically on test/tune day. Got in only 9 or 10 laps when we were forced to shut it down before the rod knock exploded the motor. Drove overnight to pick up a spare motor, got back to the track around 4:00 in the morning. Worked all day to swap motors, finally got it running and ready to go around 2:45 on Sunday afternoon. Got it back on the track for slow laps and finished under the checkered flag.

Racing a running car is great. But it pales in comparison to really gutting it out over a couple days to get things going again. There's no reason for a car going sput-sput-sput to turn any team into "instant spectators," unless they want to quit.

Lemons isn't an amusement park ride. It's an endurance race for cheapass, shitbox cars that are bound to fail. It is gritty. It is getting oil-dry in your hair while trying to get the last of the half shaft bolts on so that you can get back on the track before the light of day fades. It is the failure and the rebound from that failure that makes the race interesting, difficult, and alluring. Why mess with a successful formula?

Pat Mulry, TARP Racing #67

Mandatory disclaimer: all opinions expressed are mine alone & not those of 24HOL, its mgmt, sponsors, etc.

16 (edited by Troy 2009-12-17 09:39 AM)

Re: Is there a rule on bringing a back up car?

While I don't mind this plan.  I thought of a couple additional points.

1. Your #1 car blows up.  You are out of contention and bring in #2 to get seat time.
    If your first car was bad enough to blow up, what's stopping the second from 
    doing the same?

2. Building, preparing and transporting a second car is a large expense of both
    time and money.  Maybe it would be better to invest those resources into the
    first car to improve your odds of completing the race.

There seem to be two common causes of engine failure in cars:

1. Lubrication

2. Cooling

For teams that throw rods and suffer true catastrophic failure early in the race, there had to be some kind of missed warning sign.  Healthy motors don't tend to just died unexpectedly.

Do research on the car and driver train.  Thrown rods are probably caused more by a lubrication problem than anything else.  Since we are pretty much driving in circles all the time, that can cause oiling problems in a lot of cars.  A baffled oil pan may be the solution. 

Blown head gaskets are typical results from over heating.  Not all the time but a lot of the time.  Most cars seem to cool themselves okay with a good functioning cooling system.  MR2s on the other hand have issues with this.  So in many cases a good cooling system will prevent these problems.  Some cars may be prone to cavitation at high rpms and I don't know how to solve that cheap.

Crap Can or F1, we are trying to do things with these cars that they were not designed for (okay F1 cars are designed for this).  Add in the fact we want to do this for a long time and problems are likely. 

I keep plugging away at the problems we have had and at some point, we just might find a way to make a cheap, fast and reliable old Z. 

So maybe a better investment of a teams time is to work with what they have and try to find creative solutions to their problems.

Troy

#35 LRE
1973 Datsun 240Z

Re: Is there a rule on bringing a back up car?

dpvog wrote:

Cmice, that's great, assuming someone on your team is 23 years old, full of piss and vinegar, and has the steam to do all that wrenching and then race the next day on no sleep.  But what about a team of older guys who have a few extra pounds, maybe a touch of arthritis, and a turbulent relationship with their torque wrenches.  Should they become instant spectators for the whole weekend just because it would take them 4 days and two emergency room visits to swap out an engine?

Welcome to the 24 Hours of Lemons...

Re: Is there a rule on bringing a back up car?

The Lemons Experience (tm) is all about hardship.  This race was conceived to break cars and force their teams to fix them. 

I think I'd be OK with it if a teams car blew up after 10 laps, but if you got a whole day of racing... well that's more than we got for the first two races in which we participated.

Sounds like you guys need to recruit some 23-year-olds to do your wrenching.  Alternatively, put together a two car team with the understanding that if the #1 car breaks everyone splits time on the #2 car and vice-versa.  While you have to have 4 drivers on the sign up sheet, not all of them have to actually drive.  Drivers are also not restricted to the car they were signed up on.  So if you really want insurance, just sign up two cars and add some fake drivers to the roster to get up to your total of 4 per car.

Loverman: How did the 24 Hours of Lemons start?
Jay Lamm: Basically, with way too much beer and chinese food. We'd been doing this road-rally thing called the Double 500, a 500-kilometer road rally for $500 cars, for years. I came up with the general idea for the Double 500 one day after the California MIlle, while I was taunting Martin Swig that it was too easy for the Mille guys to just solve all their mechanical problems with a check wrench. I was pretty much just busting his chops, but Martin isn't one to take that lying down. He called my bluff, and actually wound up organizing and hosting the Double 500 as a street rally. Anyway, a few years later, a bunch of us SF car guys were sitting around at our regular Saturday lunch one day, and we all kind of agreed that the Double 500 had gotten too easy...

There were really great $500 cars everywhere, and just about any of them could make it 500 kilometers. So I just figured a 24-hour race on a track was the next level of difficulty.

In retrospect, adding the racetrack and the 24-hour duration was my way of guaranteeing that you'd have more of those panicky, hilarious mechanical crises that make vintage rallies and vintage racing so much fun. (You know, fun for the other people who are watching you suffer....)

Our Lady of Perpetual Downforce
http://www.perpetualdownforce.com/

Re: Is there a rule on bringing a back up car?

dpvog wrote:

Okay then, Bender, have it your way.  I don't care how many miles you had to walk to school barefoot.  Us spoiled kids today want it easier.  We're bringing our damn ipods, and if we've saved enough money from our paper route to spring for a second $500 car fee just to make sure we're not spending the weekend underneath a car instead of inside it, what do you care?  MOM!?!  Why does Grandpa Bender have to live with us???

Jeez I just wish you could read, I said and Quote: I guess I would have no problem with having a second car if the team was willing to pay the additional $500.00 per car for the extra insurance.
And yes Grandpa Bender has to live with us cause he is "senile" and a little bit "crazy" and he won't leave the little old ladies at the senior center alone!

Team: V-Ram/Altamont Team: Knights of the Round Track/Reno/Buttonwillow/Thunderhill Team: Death Mobile/Sears 2010/Thunderhill/ChumpCar  Spokane/ MSR Houston/Buttonwillow/Sears. MRolla Project /Reno
http://stickfigureracing.blogspot.com/

Re: Is there a rule on bringing a back up car?

dpvog wrote:

Okay then, Bender, have it your way.  I don't care how many miles you had to walk to school barefoot.  Us spoiled kids today want it easier.  We're bringing our damn ipods, and if we've saved enough money from our paper route to spring for a second $500 car fee just to make sure we're not spending the weekend underneath a car instead of inside it, what do you care?  MOM!?!  Why does Grandpa Bender have to live with us???

You are going to spend $4,000 to prep a second car, and you are worried about another $500 for entrance fees?

for what it's worth, I listen to my iPod while swapping my motors smile

Re: Is there a rule on bringing a back up car?

Mulry wrote:

At Houston, we blew up the race motor basically on test/tune day. Got in only 9 or 10 laps when we were forced to shut it down before the rod knock exploded the motor. Drove overnight to pick up a spare motor, got back to the track around 4:00 in the morning. Worked all day to swap motors, finally got it running and ready to go around 2:45 on Sunday afternoon. Got it back on the track for slow laps and finished under the checkered flag.

You left out the part about that spare engine still being in another car ... a small, but important, omission IMHO. Long live the Heroic Fix award winners.

Summer's Eve Racing - '09 Yee-Haw; '10 Gator-O-Rama, NorDal Hooptie, Yee-Haw; '11 Gator-O-Rama, NorDal Hooptie (Winner, Class A!)
TARP Racing - '11 Yee-Haw, Heaps; '12 Gator-O-Rama (Winner, Class C ... Looking for a Class B Win to Complete the Trifecta!), Heaps; '13 NorDal Hooptie, Gator-O-Rama

Re: Is there a rule on bringing a back up car?

FreeRange, my whole point was that if I WASN'T worried about the extra $500, why should anyone else care?

Re: Is there a rule on bringing a back up car?

Sorry, Mr. Bender.  I focused on your second post on the topic, and forgot to review your first.  Must be another senior moment.  I read just fine, but don't remember anything I read, so the problem is with retention, not comprehension.  And I'll tell Mom you can live with us.

Re: Is there a rule on bringing a back up car?

dpvog wrote:

FreeRange, my whole point was that if I WASN'T worried about the extra $500, why should anyone else care?

You can always do what we do...

http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3117/3111289556_1bcd73511c.jpg

that way if ANYTHING breaks.. you are guaranteed to have a back-up

Re: Is there a rule on bringing a back up car?

To paraphrase one of "Lord Lamm's" interviews;

"We realized we had the most fun when things went horribly wrong"

...and thus Lemons was born. See how far you can go with a crappy car. <---CORE

Winning, seat time, insurance, backup cars, coilovers @#$%!!!! That's all Bulls#$%.

"Real ZomBees prefer Bacon"
IOE(x2) MGB/SAAB 96, Judge's Choice, Class C Win, & 2011 Hooniverse Car of the Year!
MRolla, Stick Figure/Animal House, Free Range MR2, SAAB Sonett, "The Death Flip"
2008 Exoskeleton Jag Fiasco, Concours d Lemons - Rue Britannia, worse British car.