1 (edited by ICAustinMiniMan 2015-05-18 07:56 AM)

Topic: Subframe Engineering - Y'all know more than I do.

Hey All,

I'm in the beginning stages of trying to swap a Suzuki G10 into a 1957 Berkeley SE492. The issue is Berkeley's are exceptionally narrow; they're four feet at the widest point. A lot of people swap motorcycles engines into these, but I don't really care for the way bike-engined cars drive, and besides, I don't have a differential for one. So, in came the G10. They're exceptionally light, make decent power, and have a nice 5-speed.

The problem is that Metros don't have subframes. They're a true unibody. So I need to make a subframe for the front. Mini subframes actually fit fairly well, and making engine mounts wouldn't be too bad. However, if possible, I'd like to run Metro hubs. This would allow me to use the wheels, brakes, shocks, etc off the Metro, and would keep the cost down a lot. If I run Mini hubs, which would be the logical way to do it if I was going to use a Mini subframe, I would have to get half-shafts made that were Mini splined on one side, and Metro on the other. This is fully possible, but again, if I could retain the Metro hubs, I'd prefer it.
 
Thus, does anyone have any ideas of how they were tackle this? Should I just try to make a custom subframe that echos the Metro but narrower? I feel like building that to precise enough tolerances would be extremely difficult. I'm a mediocre fabricator at best. I'd love to learn more, of course.

I'm generally just asking for general spitballing of ideas. For reference, the Metro is 10" wider than the Berkeley. The engine and transmission is 27", and the engine bay of the Berkeley is about 26.5" (but cutting the inner fenders will create room.)

Photos of Berkeley: http://imgur.com/a/vfAxi

Photos of the soon-to-be-sacrificed Metro: http://imgur.com/a/UJmbX

Idle Clatter Racing: 1979 Mercedes 300SD Delivery Spaceship,  "Not all ideas are good."
Fall 2013 CMP I.O.E.
Shine Country Classic 2014 and Southern Discomfort: Showed Up; Didn't Blowed Up
Humidi TT: DOMINATION. Barber 2015: "Least Southern Pickup Truck"

Re: Subframe Engineering - Y'all know more than I do.

Do you have a mini subframe already?  I would highly discourage making your own subframe. 

My first instinct (based on your description) would be to adapt the metro ball joint onto the mini lower control arm.  Then you've got a pre-engineered subframe and can use all the axles, suspension, and hubs from the metro.

Make sure you play close attention to the steering rack location also.  You can introduce a tremendous amount of bump-steer into the car just from the rack location.

Knoxvegas Lowballers  Metro SVT, Multi-Powertrain-Van, The Hooptiecorn
2013 - Heroic Fix, Judge's Choice, Heroic Fix       2014 - IOE,Class-C Win
2015- Judge's Choice, Class B Win,Class A/Overall Win     2016- Org. Choice, B

3 (edited by ICAustinMiniMan 2015-05-18 10:21 AM)

Re: Subframe Engineering - Y'all know more than I do.

gm2 wrote:

Do you have a mini subframe already?  I would highly discourage making your own subframe. 

My first instinct (based on your description) would be to adapt the metro ball joint onto the mini lower control arm.  Then you've got a pre-engineered subframe and can use all the axles, suspension, and hubs from the metro.

Make sure you play close attention to the steering rack location also.  You can introduce a tremendous amount of bump-steer into the car just from the rack location.

I don't already have them, but I do have an Austin 1300 subframe which has potential. I know a place that would sell me front and rear Mini subframes for $400 though. So... just figure out a way to mount the spindle onto the Mini/Austin control arms? Seems doable depending on 107836 factors. Any advice on shortening half-shafts? And what should I know about mounting the steering rack? Just keep it as square as possible to the splindles when zero degrees of steering?

Idle Clatter Racing: 1979 Mercedes 300SD Delivery Spaceship,  "Not all ideas are good."
Fall 2013 CMP I.O.E.
Shine Country Classic 2014 and Southern Discomfort: Showed Up; Didn't Blowed Up
Humidi TT: DOMINATION. Barber 2015: "Least Southern Pickup Truck"

Re: Subframe Engineering - Y'all know more than I do.

There is a reason that the word Berkeley = the "F" word on GRM.

I wish you luck in this endeavor!

Ghetto motorsports - Car #555 1980 Mazda RX7 (3x winner of BFE GP / 1x 2nd place of BFE GP...BOO!)
Car #350 78 Chevy Malibu (Least horrible Yank Tank, Heroic Fix) (Gone)
Car # 556 1987 Mazda RX7 (6th place MMC 2013) (1st place Capitol Offense 2013)

5 (edited by gm2 2015-05-18 10:45 AM)

Re: Subframe Engineering - Y'all know more than I do.

Shorter axles for a metro engine?  I'd chop the axle in half, cut it down, sleeve it back together with some thick pipe and weld it back together.  If you want to get fancy, a decently equipped machine shop can cut it down and weld it together with full penetration or re-spline it at a shorter length.

For setting the rack location-
Assemble the suspension fully but without springs, (car on jack stands, obviously)
Get the rack where you think you want it and clamp/weld/affix it into place temporarily
use a jack to move the hub/control arm through it's normal operation travel and measure your toe at different heights  (tape measure is plenty accurate)
ideally, you want as little toe-induced as possible.  Adjust the rack as necessary to improve.

Knoxvegas Lowballers  Metro SVT, Multi-Powertrain-Van, The Hooptiecorn
2013 - Heroic Fix, Judge's Choice, Heroic Fix       2014 - IOE,Class-C Win
2015- Judge's Choice, Class B Win,Class A/Overall Win     2016- Org. Choice, B

6 (edited by ICAustinMiniMan 2015-05-18 12:16 PM)

Re: Subframe Engineering - Y'all know more than I do.

wvumtnbkr wrote:

There is a reason that the word Berkeley = the "F" word on GRM.

I wish you luck in this endeavor!

I'm well aware, sadly. That being said... I'm not trying to make my own differential, or to make 140HP handle well with a 42" track-width. I'm just trying to make a smaller Geo Metro.

Okay... the now the real challenge.

Metros are a Macpherson-strut front suspension, as seen here: http://www.bouyea.net/geos/IMG_6800s.JPG

Austin 1300's are double wishbone (in effect), as seen here: http://www.ado16.info/images/kc2003_07.jpg

So how might the Knox Vegas geniuses suggest mounting the former spindle in the latter? The bottom should be easy enough, but the top... uggh...

MUSING UPDATE:

The bottom of the spindle should be easy enough. They're both just balljoints, so that should bolt up. The top is the issue. What if I rotated the mount on the upper control arm of the Austin 90 degrees, shortened it some, and replaced the balljoint with a bushing. Then bolted the upper control arm to the stock location on the Geo spindle where it originally bolted to the strut. Then, use a coilover in the stock Austin location?

Here's a better illustration of the Austin setup: http://members.tripod.com/austin_americ … ewdone.jpg

And my idea, with stock Austin being on the right, and the hybrid setup being on the left: http://i.imgur.com/lr2vOHvl.jpg

Idle Clatter Racing: 1979 Mercedes 300SD Delivery Spaceship,  "Not all ideas are good."
Fall 2013 CMP I.O.E.
Shine Country Classic 2014 and Southern Discomfort: Showed Up; Didn't Blowed Up
Humidi TT: DOMINATION. Barber 2015: "Least Southern Pickup Truck"

Re: Subframe Engineering - Y'all know more than I do.

Would it be easy to remove the upper control arm and just convert the suspension to McPherson?

The drawing would work if you had an upper ball joint, not a bushing.  I'm guessing you want to be able to steer the car.

With that drawing, you also stand to easily introduce some wonky caster if the top 'adapter' isn't well planned.

Knoxvegas Lowballers  Metro SVT, Multi-Powertrain-Van, The Hooptiecorn
2013 - Heroic Fix, Judge's Choice, Heroic Fix       2014 - IOE,Class-C Win
2015- Judge's Choice, Class B Win,Class A/Overall Win     2016- Org. Choice, B

Re: Subframe Engineering - Y'all know more than I do.

I think I'd message Spank to get ideas.  He has a fair bit of experience/knowledge about those sub frames and might even have worked out a few of those issues in his mind if not in practice.

1990 RX7 "Mazdarita"  1964 Sunbeam Imp (IOE 2013 Sears Pointless) 2002 Jaguar x-type (Winner C-Class 2021 Sears Pointless)
Gone bye-bye
1994 Jaguar XJ12 (Winner C-Class 2013 Sears Pointless)  1980 Rover SD1 (I Got Screwed 2014 Return of Lemonites)

Re: Subframe Engineering - Y'all know more than I do.

gm2 wrote:

Would it be easy to remove the upper control arm and just convert the suspension to McPherson?

Potentially, although height is a potential concern. The fenders on Berkeleys are very low, and Macpherson designs are inherently tall.

gm2 wrote:

The drawing would work if you had an upper ball joint, not a bushing.  I'm guessing you want to be able to steer the car.

At this point, straight-only might be a safer option. Haha. I feel dumb for making that mistake, though. I forgot how the top pivot on Macphersons work.

Idle Clatter Racing: 1979 Mercedes 300SD Delivery Spaceship,  "Not all ideas are good."
Fall 2013 CMP I.O.E.
Shine Country Classic 2014 and Southern Discomfort: Showed Up; Didn't Blowed Up
Humidi TT: DOMINATION. Barber 2015: "Least Southern Pickup Truck"

Re: Subframe Engineering - Y'all know more than I do.

Here's something I found somewhere online while doing research on how to convert a macpherson suspension into double wishbone...(may have been for a Mustang...)  Custom adapter that bolts on in place of the strut and accepts a ball joint.

https://farm9.staticflickr.com/8773/17235761194_87213dbbb3_o.jpg

-Nathan - Team Captain, Priority Fail Racing
1997 Golf GTI VR6 Mid Engine

11 (edited by ICAustinMiniMan 2015-05-19 07:15 AM)

Re: Subframe Engineering - Y'all know more than I do.

the shaolin wrote:

Here's something I found somewhere online while doing research on how to convert a macpherson suspension into double wishbone...(may have been for a Mustang...)  Custom adapter that bolts on in place of the strut and accepts a ball joint.


I was actually thinking of something similar to that. Height is a problem, though. The Austin subframe only gives about 8 inches between the upper and lower control arms.

Is there such a thing as a directory of splines? I wonder if some other car out there uses the same spline as a Metro. The hub spacing is just 4x4.5 on 59.6 which is pretty common.

I did a little mocking up last night, and it's going to be tight, if it's even possible. The Suzuki engine is very narrow, but the transmission isn't. Luckily, the outputs for the transmission are fairly close to the center, so I can cut some width out without making the half-shaft angle too extreme. I'm not really sure how much of an angle is too much, really.

I was hoping that I would only have to remove 6" from that subframe. It's looking like closer to 8" or 10". That's... a lot. The transmission will definitely be over the driver side frame rail. I'm going to take some more definitive measurements tonight and start sketching widths. Uggh. This is a lot of variables.

https://scontent.fash1-1.fna.fbcdn.net/hphotos-xta1/v/t34.0-12/11328969_10206825838382103_1615182498_n.jpg?oh=e75381bbc20cd2beb37c98248a674dee&oe=555D65A0

Idle Clatter Racing: 1979 Mercedes 300SD Delivery Spaceship,  "Not all ideas are good."
Fall 2013 CMP I.O.E.
Shine Country Classic 2014 and Southern Discomfort: Showed Up; Didn't Blowed Up
Humidi TT: DOMINATION. Barber 2015: "Least Southern Pickup Truck"

Re: Subframe Engineering - Y'all know more than I do.

Inboard springs with bellcranks would allow a lower spring/shock tower height.

Planet Express
"IOE" "C Win" 4834.701 Race Miles and counting
Toyocedes
"Least Southern Pickup Truck" "IOE" "C win" "C win (again?)"

Re: Subframe Engineering - Y'all know more than I do.

My current thought it to make an adapter like the_shaolin posted, but in reverse. Make an adapter than uses a bolt-on ball joint, then use the stock Austin control arms. So both castle nuts will be on the bottom. http://i.imgur.com/WskDed3l.jpg

Idle Clatter Racing: 1979 Mercedes 300SD Delivery Spaceship,  "Not all ideas are good."
Fall 2013 CMP I.O.E.
Shine Country Classic 2014 and Southern Discomfort: Showed Up; Didn't Blowed Up
Humidi TT: DOMINATION. Barber 2015: "Least Southern Pickup Truck"

Re: Subframe Engineering - Y'all know more than I do.

The popular conversion for minis is to go honda B16 or (lately) D16. The popular kit, mintech, is all custom square tube and coilover suspension (superfastminis.com). A friend of mine designed and markets his own kit using stock mini suspension and stock geometry. He's also been working on putting the earlier Chevy Sprint motor into a mini pickup. But it's been stalled for a few years now. Looks up steve alexander and Ramco--that's the guy.

All of that said, and as someone who has made his own subframe for a non-traditional transplant-- I say you put the components you WANT to use in the location you want to have them, then start connecting the dots with tube and a welder. It ain't rocket science and you aren't trying to crame somethinh with 200ft;/bs of torque in there. Yea, you can't weld to fiberglass, but you can make a steel mounting plate that rests against the key areas of fiberglass and weld to that.

I totally bodged in a 28 hp, 848cc A-series engine and transmission into a 1985 CRX (to do a reverse vtec mini conversion) and brought it to mini meet that included an autocross. Totally worked better than you'd ever imagine and it was the hokiest p.o.s. you'd ever seen.

http://hubgarage.s3.amazonaws.com/photos/1197598/MindaMMW_01_detail.jpg
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wDdo9Qh7A_w

The ToyoHog wasn't a whole lot different. I literally took an engine hoist and hung it where I wanted it to sit (and then later some bars to brace it up--appearance was the most important thing to me) and the whole friggin' thing just worked!

http://hubgarage.s3.amazonaws.com/photos/5563393/IMG_1316_detail.jpg

http://hubgarage.s3.amazonaws.com/photos/5563437/IMG_1403_detail.JPG

Re: Subframe Engineering - Y'all know more than I do.

See that green car next to the Berkeley?

http://i.imgur.com/i5pTf71l.jpg

Yeah... I know Minitec's work. Haha

http://i.imgur.com/pPzE7G6l.jpg

As Leno would say, "This is the Japanese power British front-wheel-drive section of the garage."

I mean, in truth Spank, I am kind of putting the components I want where I want if I can get that adapter to work. I want the Metro hubs, but I'd prefer the Mini wishbones for height. So if I can make that work, and somehow be narrow enough, that'd be perfect.

Idle Clatter Racing: 1979 Mercedes 300SD Delivery Spaceship,  "Not all ideas are good."
Fall 2013 CMP I.O.E.
Shine Country Classic 2014 and Southern Discomfort: Showed Up; Didn't Blowed Up
Humidi TT: DOMINATION. Barber 2015: "Least Southern Pickup Truck"

16 (edited by the shaolin 2015-05-19 10:34 AM)

Re: Subframe Engineering - Y'all know more than I do.

ICAustinMiniMan wrote:

My current thought it to make an adapter like the_shaolin posted, but in reverse. Make an adapter than uses a bolt-on ball joint, then use the stock Austin control arms. So both castle nuts will be on the bottom. http://i.imgur.com/WskDed3l.jpg


Careful...look what that's going to do to your steering axis.  The original steering axis is an imaginary line between the lower ball joint and the top of the strut mount.  The new steering axis (between the ball joints) is going to be inclined ~30° or more from this.

I think the ball joint would need to go on top...maybe you could shorten the upper control arms?

I'd build a camber/bumpsteer gauge and start playing around with mounting points, just find something that works.

Also, found the thread I ganked that original image from, it has a few more details on how to pull it off.

http://www.locostusa.com/forums/viewtop … ;start=150

-Nathan - Team Captain, Priority Fail Racing
1997 Golf GTI VR6 Mid Engine

17 (edited by ICAustinMiniMan 2015-05-19 10:59 AM)

Re: Subframe Engineering - Y'all know more than I do.

the shaolin wrote:

Careful...look what that's going to do to your steering axis.  The original steering axis is an imaginary line between the lower ball joint and the top of the strut mount.  The new steering axis (between the ball joints) is going to be inclined ~30° or more from this.

I think the ball joint would need to go on top...maybe you could shorten the upper control arms?

I'd build a camber/bumpsteer gauge and start playing around with mounting points, just find something that works.

Also, found the thread I ganked that original image from, it has a few more details on how to pull it off.

http://www.locostusa.com/forums/viewtop … ;start=150


The angle between the upper and lower ball joint was exaggerated a lot in my drawing. It would actually be very close to straight. I would just take an Austin hub, figure out the dimensions of that, and replicate the geometry using the adapter for the upper ball joint. The hub itself it a static entity of course, so if I can make the relative angle of the hub and the mounting points the same as on the Austin hub, it should matter that the adapter if there, or that the ball joint is upside down, right?

Here's closer to what I meant:

http://i.imgur.com/sg8TyaIl.jpg

So it will just drop a balljoint below the upper mount on the Geo hub, lined up with the lower ball joint.

http://i.imgur.com/tD7lCKUl.jpg

To replicate the spacing of this:

http://i.imgur.com/SCI5tP3l.jpg

Idle Clatter Racing: 1979 Mercedes 300SD Delivery Spaceship,  "Not all ideas are good."
Fall 2013 CMP I.O.E.
Shine Country Classic 2014 and Southern Discomfort: Showed Up; Didn't Blowed Up
Humidi TT: DOMINATION. Barber 2015: "Least Southern Pickup Truck"

18

Re: Subframe Engineering - Y'all know more than I do.

Looks like a tight fit to still get the axle through there, and like the shaolin mentioned, it's got the potential to really throw off your steering axis.

I'm not seeing any better options with the parts available though.  About now is when I would start researching (walking around pull-a-part) subframes on other small fwd's before pouring hours of fab work into a complex series of workarounds.

For reference, a Pull-A-Part subframe, with brakes, steering rack, and suspension costs us $260... We've bought a bunch of them.

Knoxvegas Lowballers  Metro SVT, Multi-Powertrain-Van, The Hooptiecorn
2013 - Heroic Fix, Judge's Choice, Heroic Fix       2014 - IOE,Class-C Win
2015- Judge's Choice, Class B Win,Class A/Overall Win     2016- Org. Choice, B

Re: Subframe Engineering - Y'all know more than I do.

gm2 wrote:

Looks like a tight fit to still get the axle through there, and like the shaolin mentioned, it's got the potential to really throw off your steering axis.

I'm not seeing any better options with the parts available though.  About now is when I would start researching (walking around pull-a-part) subframes on other small fwd's before pouring hours of fab work into a complex series of workarounds.

For reference, a Pull-A-Part subframe, with brakes, steering rack, and suspension costs us $260... We've bought a bunch of them.


What would that really achieve, though? For one thing, FWD's with double wishbones are rare. And I'd still have to narrow it. And then the axles would have to be custom made because they'd be splined differently...

Idle Clatter Racing: 1979 Mercedes 300SD Delivery Spaceship,  "Not all ideas are good."
Fall 2013 CMP I.O.E.
Shine Country Classic 2014 and Southern Discomfort: Showed Up; Didn't Blowed Up
Humidi TT: DOMINATION. Barber 2015: "Least Southern Pickup Truck"

Re: Subframe Engineering - Y'all know more than I do.

At that point you're better off just going with a minitec thrown away mini front subframe I'd think.

Planet Express
"IOE" "C Win" 4834.701 Race Miles and counting
Toyocedes
"Least Southern Pickup Truck" "IOE" "C win" "C win (again?)"

21

Re: Subframe Engineering - Y'all know more than I do.

ICAustinMiniMan wrote:

What would that really achieve, though? For one thing, FWD's with double wishbones are rare. And I'd still have to narrow it. And then the axles would have to be custom made because they'd be splined differently...

Probably nothing, but you're already looking at narrowing a subframe and somewhat custom axles anyway.  If a few minutes of browsing gets you at a better starting point, or even just confirms that you're current plan is the best starting point, than it's time well spent.

Knoxvegas Lowballers  Metro SVT, Multi-Powertrain-Van, The Hooptiecorn
2013 - Heroic Fix, Judge's Choice, Heroic Fix       2014 - IOE,Class-C Win
2015- Judge's Choice, Class B Win,Class A/Overall Win     2016- Org. Choice, B

Re: Subframe Engineering - Y'all know more than I do.

ICAustinMiniMan wrote:

FWD's with double wishbones are rare.


Check out 90's Hondas...I think most of them were double wishbone, and the car is small.

-Nathan - Team Captain, Priority Fail Racing
1997 Golf GTI VR6 Mid Engine

Re: Subframe Engineering - Y'all know more than I do.

the shaolin wrote:
ICAustinMiniMan wrote:

FWD's with double wishbones are rare.


Check out 90's Hondas...I think most of them were double wishbone, and the car is small.


They do indeed, but the top of the spindle is extremely long, so it won't work. http://honda-tech.com/attachments/honda-crx-ef-civic-1988-1991-3/223568d1312256390-crx-civic-si-ex-front-suspension-questions-img_1712.jpg

My current thought is to use Mini hubs but on a custom subframe and with custom wishbones. This would, theoretically, allow me to make the frame wider for the engine by shortening the wishbones. Does anyone know the dynamics of wishbones, and why it might be a bad idea to have very short (6" or so) ones?

This appears to have good travel, the camber is agreeable, and the role center is in a good spot. Thoughts?

http://tinyurl.com/ku2zxog

Idle Clatter Racing: 1979 Mercedes 300SD Delivery Spaceship,  "Not all ideas are good."
Fall 2013 CMP I.O.E.
Shine Country Classic 2014 and Southern Discomfort: Showed Up; Didn't Blowed Up
Humidi TT: DOMINATION. Barber 2015: "Least Southern Pickup Truck"

Re: Subframe Engineering - Y'all know more than I do.

You already found Vsusp, plug in shorter wishbones and see what happens!

The shorter the wishbone, the less wheel travel you'll be able to use and the higher your spring rate will have to be to keep the suspension in a "happy" spot.

-Nathan - Team Captain, Priority Fail Racing
1997 Golf GTI VR6 Mid Engine

25 (edited by ICAustinMiniMan 2015-05-20 11:14 AM)

Re: Subframe Engineering - Y'all know more than I do.

the shaolin wrote:

You already found Vsusp, plug in shorter wishbones and see what happens!

The shorter the wishbone, the less wheel travel you'll be able to use and the higher your spring rate will have to be to keep the suspension in a "happy" spot.

That model I linked to is about what would be required to make everything fit. It has 5" lower control arms and 4.6" upper. Which... is insanely short. But it seems to work. Would you mind playing around with that model I linked and tell me what you think? I don't really know what I'm looking for...

Idle Clatter Racing: 1979 Mercedes 300SD Delivery Spaceship,  "Not all ideas are good."
Fall 2013 CMP I.O.E.
Shine Country Classic 2014 and Southern Discomfort: Showed Up; Didn't Blowed Up
Humidi TT: DOMINATION. Barber 2015: "Least Southern Pickup Truck"